Best Seafood in Islamorada

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Islamorada, FL at 81901 Overseas Hwy

Fresh caught. Family made. Since 2011.

Order online

Featured

View menu

Right on the Overseas Highway, Open Daily

Dive into fresh seafood, cherished family recipes, and authentic Keys hospitality at Islamorada Shrimp Shack. Drop by any day from 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM (Closed Wednesdays).

The Dishes People Come Back For

Shrimp n' Grits, Fish Senator, Continental Style, Shrimp Fritters — made fresh every day, the way they've always been made. Plus, there’s so much more on our menu waiting for you!

See Our Menu

Island Pours

Craving a cold one? From refreshing draft beers to tropical Keys cocktails, we’ve got the perfect pairing for your seafood feast. Give us a call at (305) 664-8433 to hear what's pouring at the Shrimp Shack today!

As seen on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives

Guy Fieri rolled into Islamorada and put three of our dishes on Guy's Picks. Locals already knew — now the whole country does.

Island Shrimp Combo

Savor the ultimate seafood combo! Featuring a mix of perfectly grilled and crispy golden-fried shrimp, served alongside a colorful medley of fresh, steamed vegetables. Dip into our creamy tartar or classic cocktail sauce for a true taste of the Keys!

Order Now

The Shack that Islamorada Built

Established in 2011, Islamorada Shrimp Shack began as a passionate, family-owned venture on the Overseas Highway. From day one, the mission has remained unchanged: welcoming locals and visitors alike with open arms, genuine Keys hospitality, and the freshest seafood the islands have to offer.

Fresh From The Kitchen

Catering from Backyard to Black Tie

We bring the Shack to you — shrimp skewers, ceviche, surf and turf platters. Flexible menus for any size event in the Keys.

Explore catering

Book Your Table

Ready for the ultimate Florida Keys dining experience? Give us a call at (305) 664-8433 to reserve your spot at Islamorada Shrimp Shack. We can't wait to serve you our fresh seafood and genuine hospitality!

Explore Our Spaces

Visit Us

Come on by, grab a seat, and let us serve you the freshest seafood in the Keys! 📍 81901 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036 📞 (305) 664-8433 🕒 Mon – Tue: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM Wed: CLOSED Thu – Sun: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM

Get Directions

The shrimp and grits were amazing, full of flavor, and absolutely delicious. The blackened fish plate was exceptional as well, perfectly cooked and seasoned. Great food and a must-visit spot while in the area for a quite inside dinner.

Kyle M.

Great dinner here last week. Unpretentious and super friendly service. Made a very welcome change from many other tourist traps in and around Islamorada. Shrimp baskets were superb and my tuna appetizer was also excellent. So glad we tried here.

Caroline W.

This was the best meal I have had in Islamorada!! The continental style on my shrimp was incredible and the service was impeccable. I can’t forget the amazing hush puppies I stole off my husbands fried conch basket was amazing. Don’t miss this place!! It is truly a hidden gem

Michele F.

Always one of our favorites when we are in the Keys. We brought our own Mahi that we caught just hours before. They cooked some of it Contenental style and some Senator style, it was all delicious! Started with a seared Ahi tuna appetizer and a perfect margarita. Everyone we encountered working there were extremely friendly, polite, and in such a good mood, almost like they loved their jobs lol. That really makes a difference. We will be back soon!

David H.